Fort Myers Arrested for Murder With Zero Witnesses

In 2016, Fort Myers Police found a deceased victim on a sidewalk. The 22-year-old man had been shot several times, although no one actually saw the shooting take place. What followed was a decade-long investigation that produced no real answers. Now, prosecutors seem confident that they have located the man responsible for the murder. But how can they be certain if there were no witnesses? How likely is a conviction in this scenario? Can a Fort Myers and Naples criminal defense lawyer help defendants who find themselves in similar situations?

“Other Information From Other Witnesses” Led to Arrest of Fort Myers Man

Although prosecutors admit that there were no witnesses who saw the actual murder, they feel confident that “other information from other witnesses” is enough to convict a 33-year-old Fort Myers man. The 2016 murder occurred at the Cypress Court Apartments, and it left the victim dead on the stairwell to his home. The authorities want to hold the defendant without bail until his trial.

Journalists, prosecutors, and investigators all seem to be celebrating this as a major victory. However, there is no real information about how this cold case was “cracked.” While various articles mention extensive analysis of existing evidence and cellphone devices, no one has explained exactly how a man was arrested with no eyewitnesses tying him to the murder. One can only hope that the courts remember that defendants are innocent until proven guilty beyond reasonable doubt.

The assumption is that the GPS data on the defendant’s phone places him at the murder scene. But how could this individual have the same phone after 10 years? If he did discard his phone, how did the authorities find it? How can they prove that it belonged to him on the night of the murder? And even if the GPS data does place him at the murder scene, this doesn’t necessarily mean that he committed the crime. He could have simply walked past the body shortly after (or before) someone else carried out the shooting.

Questions such as these will undoubtedly be explored by defense lawyers and prosecutors. It is also worth noting that there was no word from the defendant’s lawyer, and it is unclear whether he even has one. So far, we have heard a very one-sided story from a criminal justice system that probably wants to fix the blemish of a decade-old unsolved murder.

Can a Criminal Defense Attorney in Fort Myers Help Me Beat My Charges?

A Fort Myers and Naples criminal defense lawyer may be able to help you beat your charges, especially if no witnesses saw you committing your alleged crime. That being said, the absence of witnesses does not necessarily lead to an “automatic win” for defendants. Prosecutors may still present compelling evidence in these scenarios, and you need to be ready for anything. Discuss a potential defense strategy with The Foley & Wilson Law Firm today.

Sources: 

yahoo.com/news/arrest-made-2016-homicide-without-203505473.html

news-press.com/story/news/crime/2025/07/21/arrest-made-in-2016-murder-with-no-witnesses-anthony-carrozza/85313978007/

fox4now.com/downtown-fort-myers/cold-case-cracked-suspect-arrested-in-2016-fort-myers-apartment-shooting